RSS Feeds RSS | Views on ITInews | contact | terms of use | privacy 

Editorial Categories:


Forthcoming Events:

No Upcoming Events

Save by getting insurance quotes

Proudly South AfricanInforming Consumers and Financial Advisors since 1988 | Click Here to Advertise
Car, household, life and business insurance quotes

News Article : Can South Africa avoid junk status? (Part 1)
Category: Economy & Global : Local Economy
Author:Jac laubscher
Email:[email protected]
Posted:01 Feb 2016

 Email this article Comment on this Article  Print this article

The South African government does not have a growth policy

The question that is probably receiving the most public attention at the moment is whether South African sovereign bonds will be downgraded to below investment grade (junk bond status) by one or more of the major credit rating agencies in the near future.

Apart from the negative practical implications such a development would have on the availability and cost of capital there seems to be a psychological revulsion to being described as “junk”.

It is therefore not only the financial cost of a downgrade that is at stake (firstly for the South African state, but also for the corporate sector as its rating depends on that of the sovereign) but also the national self-esteem!

The consensus view seems to be that the looming ratings decision depends exclusively on the health of government finances and that the upcoming national budget will therefore be decisive in determining the outcome.

The view seems to be in particular that if South Africa can demonstrate a credible commitment to stabilising the level of government debt and eventually reducing it, everything will be fine. I am afraid things are not as simple as that.

What is under scrutiny is the South African government’s capacity for analysing and understanding the country’s economic position, determining what its priorities should be, formulating the necessary economic policies to give substance to these priorities, and executing the chosen policies successfully.

After all, the future of the South African economy does not depend only on the state of the fiscal accounts but also on its performance in all its diversity and complexity, involving all role players.

The outstanding feature of recent pronouncements by credit rating agencies on South Africa is the emphasis being put on economic growth, or more accurately the lack thereof. And not only growth in the short run, but also South Africa’s long-term potential growth rate.

For example, when Standard & Poor’s announced on 4 December 2015 that it was changing the outlook for South Africa’s sovereign credit rating from stable to negative, it motivated its decision by declaring that “the negative outlook reflects our view that GDP growth might be lower than we currently expect”.

Furthermore, “we could lower the ratings if GDP growth does not improve in line with our current expectations”.

On the positive side S&P declared that “we could revise the outlook back to stable if we observe policy implementation leading to improving business confidence and increasing private sector investment, and ultimately contributing to higher GDP growth”.

Given the importance of economic growth to the sustainability of government debt, summarised in the requirement that the growth rate should exceed the interest rate on government debt in real or nominal terms, their concern is understandable.

At the moment South Africa does not meet this requirement on new debt, and the more the interest rate increases, the higher the required growth rate will become.

The fact of the matter is that South Africa’s growth prospects for 2016 and 2017 are already significantly lower that the latest forecasts of the rating agencies, making a downgrade to junk status a real possibility.

As recently as December 2015 S&P and Fitch respectively forecasted a growth rate of 1,6% and 1,7% for South Africa in 2016 while the latest indications are that it will be less than 1%.

Forecasts for 2017 are similarly over-optimistic and will inevitably be cut.

One of the occupational hazards of commenting on the South African economy for so long as I have been doing is the frustration of repeating yourself over and over again and to see little progress being made on critical structural issues holding back the economy.

Economic growth, the need to make it an absolute priority, and the formulation and implementation of a comprehensive set of policies to create a favourable environment for growth top the list.

That is why the South African government’s new-found zeal to improve the growth rate of the economy does not excite me.

In a commentary on economic growth I wrote last year I made the statement that the South African government did not have a growth policy.

It still does not have one. To believe that calling a meeting of government, business and labour will somehow propel us onto a higher growth trajectory is naive.

The idea that we can decide on a growth rate and then manipulate the determinants of growth to ensure the desired result à la China is completely unrealistic.

China’s struggle to come to grips with the impossibility of manipulating consumer spending (the future driver of growth) as it has manipulated investment spending (the growth driver of the past) through state-controlled credit and public investment, a large part of which was wasteful, is only starting now.

Government will do well to acknowledge that economic growth is not an objective one can directly achieve by doing this and that.

All that one can do is to create the necessary conditions and allow growth to happen!

As pointed out by Adair Turner in his Lionel Robbins Memorial Lectures delivered in October 2010, economic growth “should not be considered the objective of economic policy, but rather the highly likely outcome … of two things desirable in themselves – economic freedom to make choices, and a spirit of continual enquiry and desire for change”.

Government will do well to adopt these two principles as the foundation for creating conditions favourable for higher growth.

The first thing they (government) should do is to blow the dust off their own insights into what needs to be done for South Africa to flourish, starting with the National Development Plan (NDP), to which little more than lip service has been paid.

It will also do no harm to revisit the Accelerated and Shared Growth Initiative for South Africa (ASGISA) that was shelved by the Zuma administration (and replaced with the Industrial Policy Action Plan and New Growth Path) for no apparent reason apart from the fact that it was the brainchild of the Mbeki administration, which perhaps also explains the lack of enthusiasm for the NDP.

At the risk of further frustration, I will repeat myself yet again. South Africa will have to find a better balance between promoting economic transformation and going for higher growth.

Economic growth can no longer be relegated to a distant second place. The two objectives are after all not mutually exclusive ? it will be so much easier to achieve transformation targets in a high-growth environment.

The prioritisation of social objectives will also have to take a step back. If we can pursue policy measures needed for economic growth with the same vigour and dedication as we bring to the pursuit of social objectives, our chances of success will improve significantly.

As for avoiding junk status, the second part of this deliberation will deal with the required steps to be taken in the budget before coming to a conclusion.

There are no comments at this stage. Be the first to comment!
Please Login To Comment On an Article - Click here To Login

ITInews invites comments at the foot of each of its articles in which readers can respond freely - anonymously if they wish - to various topical issues and industry debates. However, comments submitted by readers that are defamatory or deemed, by the editors, to be racist or obscene will be deleted from the database. Furthermore, ITInews's editor would like to caution potential posters on its websites that while it welcomes robust debate, it will not hesitate to make the IP addresses of the authors of such defamatory statements available to the authorities, in the event of a court order compelling them to do so.

Get car, home, life and business insurance quotes in 3 easy steps

Join us today

Insurance Quotes

Car Insurance Quotes
Household Insurance Quotes
Business Insurance Quotes
Funeral Insurance Quotes
Life Insurance Quotes

Read the InsuranceQuotes Blog

Economy & Global - Local Economy
Disaster Insurance
Global Economy
Local Economy

More in Economy & Global : Local Economy
Can South Africa avoid junk status? (Part 2)
The risk of a downgrade in the near future is relatively high
South Africa falls short of national savings ‘pass rate’: first Savings Index launched
Investec GIBS Savings Index
Aligning monetary and fiscal policy
Is a tightening of monetary policy in conjunction with an unavoidably tight fiscal policy the best o
The effect of indigenisation, such as BEE, on financial development
Indigenisation as an economic intervention is frustrated by high levels of corruption
The insolvency U-turn
Euler Hermes Economic Outlook 2015-16
Where will growth come from? Part 2
A possible growth strategy in the current global environment
The (not-so-) hidden message of the Medium Term Budget
South Africa needs to reconstruct social consensus behind a path of accelerated economic growth
Where will growth come from?
The absence of an inherently independent growth dynamic in the economy
Contracting GDP detrimental to SME development
2015 was expected to be a better year ...
The SARB and the carry trade
Trying to support the exchange rate of the rand by hiking interest rates is an exercise in futility
Why small business does not create jobs
In South Africa we are self-employed out of necessity
The state of South Africa’s political economy
A pragmatic rather than an ideological approach
The Fall in Private Investment
South Africa’s potential growth rate has suffered long-term damage
The Management of Government Debt
South Africa runs the risk of its credit rating being downgraded
A few thoughts on the slide in oil prices
The implications of lower oil prices for South Africa are numerous and mostly advantageous
SA consumers cut back on socialising as tough economic conditions
But gifting still a significant portion of budget
Visa African Integration Index shows improvement
But long way off the global median
South African digital economy the most developed in Africa – MasterCard Index
South Africa, Egypt, Kenya and Nigeria are quickly moving towards digital evolution
The threat of secular stagnation
It is generally accepted that structural reforms are the only answer
A medium-term budget: an effort to draw the line
Weak economic performance has enforced material consolidation of fiscal policy

Join ITInews in supporting

Available Recruitment:
No Vacancies Listed...

ITM Website Design Cape Town
Copyright © 2005 - 2015 ITInews Online Publications (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved Insurance Times & Investments Online and ITInews. ..::ISSN 1995-1256::.. No part of the materials including graphics or logos, available in this Web site may be copied, photocopied, reproduced, translated or reduced to any electronic medium or machine-readable form, in whole or in part, without specific permission from ITInews Online Publications (Pty) Ltd. Distribution for commercial purposes is prohibited.