RSS Feeds RSS | Views on ITInews | contact | terms of use | privacy 

Editorial Categories:


Forthcoming Events:

No Upcoming Events

Save by getting insurance quotes

Proudly South AfricanInforming Consumers and Financial Advisors since 1988 | Click Here to Advertise
Car, household, life and business insurance quotes

News Article : The FSR Bill must under go a socioeconomic impact assessment (SEIA) to protect consumers
Category: Advisers & Brokers : Commission & Fees
Author:Jayne Boccaleone
Email:[email protected]
Posted:26 Nov 2015

 Email this article Comment on this Article  Print this article

Consumers rights and interests are scarcely mentioned

Consumers will be the losers if the Financial Sector Regulation Bill (FSRB) is enacted and parliament should demand a socio economic impact assessment (SEIA) before this bill goes any further.

This is the message from the Free Market Foundation (FMF) executive director Leon Louw who led oral evidence to the Standing Committee on Finance yesterday, 25 November.

Impact assessments are required by the Cabinet, the Presidency and the Treasury’s own Minister Hlanhla Nene, who made mention of them in his recent Medium-Term Budget Speech.

Louw said, “The FMF uses a consumer-centric approach regarding financial policy therefore we pay special attention to the cost-benefit implications for consumers of market conduct regulation of the kind envisaged in the FSRB.”

Louw stated that, although the 2011 National Treasury Policy Document claims, under the heading “A Safer Financial Sector to Serve South Africa Better”, that

“The financial services sector is at the heart of the South African economy and touches the life of each and every citizen,” little or no input has been received from consumers and their rights and interests are scarcely mentioned.

Without a professionally, properly and independently conducted SEIA, government has no way of knowing whether benefits are likely to exceed costs, what those benefits and costs are likely to be, who will enjoy benefits and who will endure costs, what the nature and extent of costs and benefits might be, and how society and the country’s economy will be impacted.

The Bill under consideration proposes the “twin peaks” system of regulation. The first, prudential regulation peak has been the norm in most countries for many years.

It is the second peak, “market conduct”, which will regulate the behaviour of the financials services industry, including insurance, under the FSB that is in particular need of a SEIA.

The intention is to have to “intensive and intrusive” interference in the operations of insurance companies.

Under Twin Peaks, South Africa will be importing failed regulation from the UK introduced to address an earlier problem, which arose from the UK equivalent of FAIS.

Since neither the Bill nor any of the voluminous documentation surrounding it provides any detailed or objective criteria for what market conduct regulation might be, parliament is being asked to empower the Financial Services Board (FSB) to do something unknown and unknowable.

The only solution to avoid this situation would be for parliament to undertake a comprehensive and independent SEIA to clarify, specify and quantify the anticipated benefits, costs and outcomes.

“After all, there is legal opinion to the effect that section 33 of our Constitution (the administrative justice clause) could mean that all legislation must be preceded by something amounting to a SEIA”, said Louw.

“It is not even clear whether there is a problem in need of a solution, the “mischief factor” which all legislation must be designed to address has not been identified."

"As long as consumers have any freedom of choice at all, they will make mistakes. Freedom is the right to be wrong. All regulatory (as opposed to educational) attempts at improving consumer behaviour, raise costs and reduce choices."

"Why should insurance be regarded as a special case? There are no regulations aimed at reducing “mis-selling” of houses, cars or wedding rings, even though the implications for consumers of making sub-optimal decisions are usually more severe”.

For over 100 years, South Africa’s system of regulation has been successful with few failures in financial services. It is based on a simple golden rule: one market, one regulator.

Splitting oversight between two regulators will create enormous and expensive compliance issues for companies already straining under excessive and burdensome existing regulations and red tape.

In the end the consumer will pay in higher premiums, reduced choice and limited independent expert advice.

“Parliament should return the FSR Bill to Treasury with an instruction to resubmit it only with a properly conducted, independent and professional SEIA, and should make it clear that, in the absence of such a SEIA, parliament is in no position to perform its legislative function properly."

"By doing this, parliament will do justice to the country and all who live in it,” said Louw.

There are no comments at this stage. Be the first to comment!
Please Login To Comment On an Article - Click here To Login

ITInews invites comments at the foot of each of its articles in which readers can respond freely - anonymously if they wish - to various topical issues and industry debates. However, comments submitted by readers that are defamatory or deemed, by the editors, to be racist or obscene will be deleted from the database. Furthermore, ITInews's editor would like to caution potential posters on its websites that while it welcomes robust debate, it will not hesitate to make the IP addresses of the authors of such defamatory statements available to the authorities, in the event of a court order compelling them to do so.

Get car, home, life and business insurance quotes in 3 easy steps

Join us today

Insurance Quotes

Car Insurance Quotes
Household Insurance Quotes
Business Insurance Quotes
Funeral Insurance Quotes
Life Insurance Quotes

Read the InsuranceQuotes Blog

Advisers & Brokers
Best Advice
Commission & Fees
FAIS Registration
National Lobby

More in Advisers & Brokers
Old Mutual responds to excess fees criticism
Commission & Fees
System defaults and the epidemic of one
Joint Brokers Forum statement on CMS remuneration proposals for healthcare intermediaries
Commission & Fees
JBF opposed to any proposals that would contravene fair competition
Unintended negative consequences for many
Commission & Fees
BHF statement questioned
Insurance Commission Regulation: Inappropriate and Undesirable
Commission & Fees
Global trend concerning commission is one of deregulation combined with increased disclosure
Transition arrangements for new commission dispensation
Commission & Fees
Broker comments
What is the real return?
Best Advice
Is there a reason they don’t want us to have this information at our finger tips?
Letter to the Editor
Commission & Fees
Banging your head against a wall burns 150 calories an hour
Intermediaries laud consumer protection
National Lobby
Critical that life assurance companies address these issues in their product re-development
How can a Broker be the underwriter?
There is a definite conflict of interest that is not in the best interest of the consumer
It seems that the independent broker is on a hiding to nothing
Commission & Fees
We need to really have our views heard or the independent will largely disappear
Behind the IGF
Commission & Fees
A question of guarantees
Letter to the Editor - some form of reform is needed
Commission & Fees
Proactive engagement with the LOA, FSB and National Treasury is needed
The case for a national South African intermediary lobby
National Lobby
Consider the formation of an all-inclusive representative umbrella forum
Life Assurance Costs
Commission & Fees
Broker wrangle
Smoke screen
Commission & Fees
Ludicrous proposals, says IBC
On the table
Commission & Fees
The industry finally agrees to review practice
Two sides
Commission & Fees
What about life company charges?
Reforms at last . . .
Commission & Fees
A bit of history
Financial Advice
Choose your financial adviser carefully
Fais Licensing
FAIS Registration
The deadline date

Join ITInews in supporting

Available Recruitment:
No Vacancies Listed...

ITM Website Design Cape Town
Copyright © 2005 - 2015 ITInews Online Publications (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved Insurance Times & Investments Online and ITInews. ..::ISSN 1995-1256::.. No part of the materials including graphics or logos, available in this Web site may be copied, photocopied, reproduced, translated or reduced to any electronic medium or machine-readable form, in whole or in part, without specific permission from ITInews Online Publications (Pty) Ltd. Distribution for commercial purposes is prohibited.